@foreach ($students as $student) @php $grade = $student->studentgrades ? $student->studentgrades->where('subject_id', $subject)->first() ?? '*' : '*'; @endphp @endforeach

Student	Examnumber	Mark	Grade
{{ $student->lastname }} {{ $student->firstname }} {{ $student->middlename }}	{{ $student->examnumber }}	{{ $grade->mark ?? '*' }}	{{ $grade->grade ?? '*' }}